By Scott Bragg, LPC, CAADC, CCTP

Fatherhood comes with certain expectations. These expectations are brought on by our partners, family members, friends, and society as a whole. Our own expectations are perhaps the most impactful. Many new dads want to be the perfect parent, partner, and provider. It is great to have high standards, especially as it relates to the vital role of being a father. On the other hand, perfectionism can lead to unnecessary stress and disappointment.
This blog takes a look at how perfectionism can be a trap for dads. Here a few ways that a new dad can be affected by perfectionism.
Perfectionism blocks joy
Perfectionism often leads unhealthy thought patterns. Unfortunately, unhealthy thought patterns cause us to only focus on extremes. We don’t “take the good with the bad” and we see mistakes as “catastrophic”. Setbacks are viewed as worst case scenarios and not as an opportunity for learning and improvement. The skewed thought patterns distract us from being more present with our children. As a result, we miss out on experiencing joy.
Perfectionism leads to fear of failure
Perfectionism breeds a mindset that we must avoid failure. It causes us to worry about possible mistakes and hyperfocus on not making the wrong decisions. Dads need the confidence and independence to care for a child. This is true when dealing with a baby (ie. tasks such as swaddling, diaper changing, bottle feeding, etc) and with older children (ie. meeting emotional needs). Allowing for growth and tolerating mistakes can make us improve on all aspects of fatherhood. We can accomplish new things when we aren’t stifled by worrying about mistakes.
Perfectionism is related to poor coping
Perfectionistic thinking negatively affect mental health. It is linked with low self-esteem, depression, anxiety, and other related issues. Also, perfectionists tend to compare themselves to others in a non-productive way. They also are known to be their worst critics. Dads, in particular, are less present with their kids when dealing with significant mental health issues. On the other hand, healthy dads will lead to healthy kids.
Having high standards as a dad is admirable. It is, on the other hand, healthier to have realistic expectations. Values and standards help us strive to be the best version of ourselves. However, perfectionism often suppresses joy, leads to a fear of failure, and leads to unhealthy coping strategies. Alternatively, sharing joy, being ourselves, showing humility, and modeling resilience are among the qualities that make great dads. These qualities will, of course, influence children in a such a positive way.

Scott Bragg is a Licensed Professional Counselor and Certified Addictions Counselor in Pennsylvania. This blog is intended for entertainment purposes only and should not substitute seeking mental health treatment.
Sources:
Gong, X., Fletcher, K., & Bolin, J. (7/2013), Dimensions of Perfections Mediate The Relationship Between Parenting Styles and Coping., Vol 93 , 259-268, Journal of Counseling and Development.
Cornwall, G (8/22), When Perfect is a Pitfall: Recognizing Perfectionism in Students, and Books to Help Them. , 30-33, School Library Journal.
DiBartolo P., Lee C., & Frost R., (7/2007), How Do the Dimensions of Perfectionism Relate to Mental Health., 401-416, Springer Science and Business Media.













